Andrew Harrison

THERE is little doubt that the introduction of the Merit Rating system of handicapping has had a profound effect on racing in this country. In its purest form it has its merits but I would argue that the local horse population is not big enough for the system to work effectively.

This is proven by the introduction of a myriad of special dispensations for various categories of races, introduced in reaction to try and plug frailties in the system. This, to a point where many trainers and, more importantly the majority of punters, are left guessing.

Jack’s Bird, a winner of one race and two placings from nine starts finds herself giving weight to all in the Greyville Convention Centre Handicap that heads the card on the poly at Hollywoodbets Greyville on Wednesday.

Michael Roberts’s filly has paid dearly for finishing close-up in weak feature company. She was on her way down the ratings from a high mark of 100 before the KZN Fillies Guineas where she finished 3,6 lengths behind Missisippi Burning. But her sixth place shunted her back up five pounds from her 90-rating going into the Guineas without earning a cent.

In other jurisdictions that use the MR system, horses capable of performing in Graded company seldom run in handicaps.

So, this race will be a test. After the Guineas, Jack’s Bird was given a break where she finished nearly five lengths back in a 1200m sprint. That should have brought her along nicely into this 1600m event and from a good draw, Roberts and her supporters will be hoping that the handicappers have it right.

One of the major complaints of the current MR system is that a horse like four-time winner Song Of The Forest, has earned R200k more than Jack’s Bird but has a MR of 81. With Jabu Jacobs claiming his 2.5kg allowance on Brett Crawford’s filly, Jacks Bird will be conceding 8.5kg to her rival that has been in cracking form of late.

In a leap of faith, Jack’s Bird is taken to get the better of Song Of The Forest, but with no confidence.