David Thiselton

THE WSB Summer Cup to be run over 2000m on Turffontein Standside on Saturday is one of the country’s big three races and is always a particularly exciting betting heat as the handicap weight structure gives most of the twenty runners a chance.

There will have been plenty of rain during the build up and the going is likely to be on the soft side.

SUMMER PUDDING is unbeaten in eight starts but will have to break a weight carrying record for a female in this race as the 59kg she has been set is 1kg more than Dancewiththedevil carried to victory in 2011. She also has to overcome a wide draw of 18 and this is the first time she faces males, so it is not surprising she has drifted out to a more realistic 7/2 with the sponsors. There are plenty of plus sides to her chances though. Wide draws in soft going are sometimes not much of a disadvanatage at Turffontein Standside because in such conditions the riders have been known to head for the standside in the straight . Summer Pudding always does just enough to win and having come back from her holiday looking full of substance and well being her big stride could well and truly carry her into the hearts of the nation.

CHARLES will attempt to give Mike de Kock a tenth Summer Cup victory and has been backed into joint 7/2 favourite. He is by Trippi out of the Ipi Tombe Challenge winner Demanding Lady, a Dynasty mare whose five wins were from 1200m to 2200m. He has finished second over 2400m before and has enjoyed a good preparation. He has the rounded action suited to soft going and has won in such conditions before. He runs off a competitive merit rating of 110. 

PACK LEADER, al;so backed in to 7/2, has blossomed since joining Alec Laird’s yard on the Highveld and is attractively weighted considering he finished seventh in the Sun Met on weight for age terms against most of the best in the country. He now carries just 54.5kg off a 109 merit rating. He is suited to the galloping nature of Turffontein Standside with its long straight. He has a good draw of five and his jockey S’Manga Khumalo, who has won this race before, needs no introduction. One possible concern is soft going, as he has a daisy-cutting action, which is usually best suited to fast going. 

CHRISTOPHER ROBIN’S two stakes wins have both been in rain affected ground and he impressed when winning the Grade 3 Victory Moon Stakes over 1800m on the Standside track under S’Manga Khumalo. He was given an eleven point merit rating raise so it will be tougher this time but he carries a nice galloping weight of 54kg. He will relish the step up to 2000m and is drawn well in two. Dennis Schwarz is an able replacement for Khumalo and will be out to make it two Summer Cup victories in succession.

ASTRIX should finish together with Christopher Robin on form. Concerns have been raised about him seeing out the trip based on his pedigree and his Grade 1 SA Classic run. His sire Vercingetorix is imparting more speed and less stamina than does his father Silvano. Furthermore, his dam is a half-sister to Thunder Dance who did win the Paddock Stakes but was essentially a miler. However, his damsire Victory Moon gives him a shout of staying and it should also be borne in mind that in the SA Classic he was caught wide throughout. Last time in the Victory Moon over 1800m he had to do some early work to overcome another wide draw yet stayed on well for second. He is now well drawn so should get cover and pace master Piere Strydom is in the irons.

TIERRA DEL FUEGO’S five length third at weight for age terms in the Champions Challenge reads well here. He has three wins, a second and a third in five outings on rain affected ground and his rider Gavin Lerena has won this race three times. However, he does have a tough draw of 14 to overcome and has to carry joint-topweight over a distance which stretches him.

TRISTFUL has been staying at Stuart Pettigrew’s yard and will have come on from his Charity Mile run. That run came about three weeks after he had arrived on the Highveld, which is usually around the time horses traveling up to the altitude hit a flat spot. On the form of his Grade 1 Champions Cup fifth place finish he has a definite chance. He will enjoy the course and distance as well as the conditions, having won on the soft before. The pace should be on so his pole position draw could well be an advantage.

DIVINE ODYSSEY is a long-striding sort who is capable of a strong finish but takes a while to find topgear and thus enjoys the long straight of the Turffontein Standside course. He has won twice in soft going and usually peaks for big races, so could be a threat.

ZILLZAAL strode out well in the Charity Mile and was entitled to tire late in his first run for eleven months. Sean Tarry said he had come out of that race well, so he is sure to make a bold bid to defend his crown.

CROWN TOWERS is proven in soft going. Wet weather is also known to make it easier for horses to handle the effects of high altitude. He is by Epsom Derby winner Camelot, so will enjoy this tough 2000m course and distance.

TREE TUMBO has always been rated by Tarry and is improving in the typical style of a Silvano four-year-old, so from a good draw is a dark horse. He is out of a sprint-miler by Oasis Dream and still has to prove he stays this trip. However, he was the fastest finisher in the Charity Mile and in his only attempt at this trip, when unplaced in the Daily New 2000, he pulled up with an abscess. 

CORNISH POMODORO is 1.5kg under sufferance but has improved with gelding. He was doing his best work late in his comeback over 1600m, so should relish this trip, and he had excuses for his below par run in the Charity Mile.

YOUCANTHURRYLOVE finished a close third in both the Grade 1 SA Classic and Charity Mile and is well drawn. He is by Gimmethegreenlight out of a Jallad mare who won up to 1800m and he is a half-brother to a horse who won over the Summer Cup trip. Chase Maujean would have learnt something from his Charity Mile run so he has a shout.

HERO’S HONOUR has dropped to a competitive mark for a former SA Derby winner but does have a tough draw.

RUNNING BRAVE is usually ignored in the betting but proof of her class is that she comes out on top in her one on one clash with the champion Celtic Sea and she stays this trip. Her best performances have been against females but she will be dangerous if getting to the front from draw ten.

RIVERSTOWN could play an important role if he is used as pacemaker for Summer Pudding. He could otherwise be a threat for although he has given the impression he would prefer shorter he should easily stay this trip on pedigree. His sire Byword won a Group 1 over a mile and two furlongs at Royal Ascot and his dam won over a mile and four furlongs in yielding going in Ireland.

VICTORIA PAIGE sneaks into the handicap with the minimum weight. She is capable of plugging on resolutely but has the widest draw of all to overcome.

ATYAAB is a former Cape Derby winner and finished fifth last year. He has not run for 301 days but did put up a good recent grass gallop.

DANCE CLASS is 3.5kg under sufferance but stayed on well in the Victory Moon over 1800m. She will relish the step up in trip as well as the possible testing conditions just as her close relative Dancewiththedevil did when winning this race in 2011.

SEVEN PATRIOTS has his toughest task to date here and is half-a-kilogram under sufferance. He is yet to try the distance but although being by Soft Falling, who was a miler, his Australian-bred dam finished a narrow second in the Grade 2 Gold Bracelet over this trip. He could be a threat if allowed an easy lead from a good draw of six.

David Thiselton

JUSTIN SNAITH said the decision to run Crown Towers in the Grade 1 WSB Summer Cup was largely as a show of support for the like of MOD (Mary Oppenheimer and Daughters), Mike de Kock and the RA, who had done a lot to save Cape racing.

He said, “They have always supported our racing and Mike de Kock has often said I am too scared to come up to Johannesburg but Crown Towers and Keep The Lights On (who runs in the Grade 3 WSB Magnolia Handicap) are just the first two, we are going to raid regularly from now on.”

Crown Towers was brought back down to Summerveld after his unplaced run in the Charity Mile.

Snaith said, “That was a bit on the short side, he has always been more impressive over further.”

Snaith said it had not been easy to prepare him because of the amount of rain there had been at Summerveld, but he added this had just made it more challenging and it was not going to change his chances.

He said, “I am very happy with his preparation. Whether he is good enough to win it, time will tell.”

He is also happy with Keep The Lights On and gives her a shout.

Snaith could not use the usual method of traveling the horses overnight and arriving on the morning of the race because of recent incidents of unrest on the Highway at night.

The pair of horses thus arrived in Johannesburg today (Friday).

A point in their favour is the rain that is around. Wet weather is believed to make it easier for horses coming from the coast to handle the high altitude of the Highveld. It should also be born in mind that Summerveld is not at sea level but is in fact a third of the altitude of the Highveld and horses have traveled from there to win over long distances before.

Michael Clower

GLEN KOTZEN has decided to have no runners for the next fortnight after a mysterious and undetectable virus forced him to scratch all his 12 horses at Kenilworth on Wednesday.

“The horses ran so badly at the last meeting (he ran 11 – only one made the frame, four finished last and another four were second last) that I have decided to pull the plug. I will give them all 14 days off and have no runners during that period. Once they start freshening up again we will start nominating.

“It’s a respiratory infection but it shows nothing and there are no symptoms. The horses look good, they work well, eat up and don’t cough. But when they get to the 400m mark, and the jockey starts asking them, they stop as if they had been shot.

“Last Saturday’s runners looked fine beforehand, we lung-washed them and the bloods were good to go yet they ran badly. The quickest way to get rid of something like this is not to run anything.”

It has been a tough week for the Woodhill trainer. On Monday he was fined R35 000 as a urine sample taken from Herodotus, after winning a race at Kenilworth over two years ago, was found to contain traces of a human painkiller. Seemingly this came from the urine of one of the stable staff.

But Kotzen, typically, is looking beyond this week’s bad news, reasoning that the Cape season is only just getting into gear and that his present patient approach can pay big dividends in the next three months.

It was 4.45am on Wednesday when Eric Sands found out that he was in trouble. “Rainbow Bridge had traces of urticaria on his neck and cheek. It’s an allergy, like somebody coming out in a rash, and it can happen in a few minutes. By the time I checked out the rest of the string it had gone down his shoulder.

“I wasn’t going to wait until it covered his whole body. I had to give him treatment and I couldn’t run him after doing that.’

Obviously the treatment would show up in any post-race dope test and the horse would be disqualified. Not treating him, and letting him run, was not an option either. “True, he might have won by six lengths but he was 5-10 and, if he was beaten, what would that have done for the public, the horse and myself? Running him would have been absolute stupidity and I certainly wasn’t going to risk it.”

Last year’s Met winner will now start off in the Green Point on December 12 and unfortunately his second run back, the one where he tends to run a bit flat, will be the L’Ormarins Queen’s Plate on 9 January.

They say they never come back but Captain Of Stealth, struck down by serious injury after looking a star of the future last season, put up a truly eye-catching performance in today’s Tabonline.co.za Pinnacle.

True, the race took a lot less winning without Rainbow Bridge but Sean Veale’s mount pulled his way to the front early and looked as if he might just hold on a furlong out. At the line he only went down by three-quarters of a length to the fellow Vaughan Marshall-trained Silver Operator in the Mario Ferreira colours and, if he stays sound, his day will surely come.

“I was very happy with Captain Of Stealth,” said Marshall, “and I think we will look at the Green Point with Silver Operator.”

African Night Sky, running for the first time since the 2018 Durban July, finished last but Justin Snaith was far from disheartened, saying: “He was very keen, too above himself and too excited – but he had only had the one grass gallop in all the time he has been off.”

A panel discussion focussing on Saturday’s World Sports Betting Gauteng Summer Cup at Turffontein will be broadcast on Tellytrack at 19:45 this evening.

The panel comprises commentator and host Alistair Cohen and trainers Sean Tarry, Alec Laird and Paul Peter, who will saddle unbeaten four-year-old filly Summer Pudding and stablemates Astrix and Riverstown in the Cup.

The show will be broadcast again tomorrow night after the last race at Chelmsford City at 21:00.

David Thiselton

ALEC LAIRD said Pack Leader had come through his two WSB Summer Cup preparation runs well but believed he would have to “run the race of his life” to win the big 2000m event at Turffontein Standside on Saturday.

Pack Leader was not given any merit rating raise after his 4,50 length win in a Progress Plate over 1600m last time out.

He won that race effortlessly despite the lead rein having mistakenly been left attached to his bridle and lashing around in front of him before S’Manga Khumalo managed to gather it up around the turn.

The six-year-old Philanthropist gelding seems to have blossomed since joining Laird’s Randjesfontein yard.

Laird said a change could be as good as a holiday and added he was also suited to the tracks on the Highveld before pointing out he had been just as good a horse with Glen Kotzen.

“Those last two runs were quite easy races and he has not had the chance to run in such plate races for quite a while.”

Pack Leader’s seventh place finish in the Sun Met, beaten 6,70 lengths on weight for age terms, proves Laird’s point.

In that race he had One World, Rainbow Bridge, Hawwaam, Twist Of Fate, Bunker Hunt, and Vardy ahead of him and among the horses he beat were Undercover Agent and Do It Again. He had also beaten Undercover Agent and Do It Again in the Green Point Stakes about seven weeks earlier.

He now runs off a 109, which ranges from 13 to 25 points lower than the respective merit ratings of the aforementioned horses he mixed it with in the Met.  

On the other hand he ran disappointingly in a number of lesser races last season and hence the seven point drop in his merit rating from the 116 it was at the time of the Met.

However, one of his most eyecatching runs last season was in the Cup Trial at Scottsville over 1800m when running on strongly from last to finish fourth. 

That run and his Met run, when coming from near the back, gave indicators that he would appreciate the galloping nature and long straights of Highveld courses like Turffontein Standside and the Vaal. And so it has proved.

He is enjoying himself on the Highveld too, so looks set to reproduce that Met run. 

One possible detractor is he has the daisy-cutting type of action that is usually best suited to fast ground.

Therefore, Laird was asked if he foresaw any problems Pack Leader would have handling soft going. 

He said, “We don’t work them on soft going so it is always difficult to tell. I think if there is just a bit of cut in the ground he should be fine although if it turns out heavy it will be difficult for any horse unless he or she is a mudlark.”    

There is rain forecast most days this week in Johannesburg so the going is likely to be on the soft side. 

Pack Leader jumps from a plum draw of four and has a nice galloping weight of 54,5kg with S’Manga Khumalo in the irons.  

Laird won the Summer Cup in 2006 with the Rakeen colt Malteme, who converted 14/1 odds carrying 51kg under Brett Smith. 

Khumalo has also won it one once, aboard the Joey Soma-trained Wagner, who converted odds of 16/1 in 2012 carrying 52.5kg.

David Thiselton

PIERE STRYDOM is the winning-most Summer Cup rider to be taking part in Saturday’s big race, having been in the winner’s enclosure of Johannesburg’s flagship event four times, and he will need to cause an upset to increase his tally as he is aboard the 25-1 chance Astrix.

Strydom has never ridden the Paul Peter-trained four-year-old Vercingetorix gelding but has spoken to his regular rider Warren Kennedy. The latter confirmed there was a bit of a concern he would stay the tough 2000m trip. 

Vercingetorix is appearing to impart more speed and less stamina in his progeny than his prolific sire Silvano does. However, Astrix’s damsire Victory Moon, who won a Grade 3 and a Grade 2 over 2000m and was an unlucky fifth in the Group 1 Eclipse Stakes over 2007m, provides some hope he will stay. On the other hand Astrix’s dam Victory Dance is a half-sister to the dual Grade 1 winner Thunder Dance (Jet Master), who was essentially a miler. Furthermore, his second dam Shadow Dancing is a half-sister to the speed influence Captain Al. 

However, the point that does give hope is that both Astrix’s attempts at 1800m to date did not pan out well. He was caught wide throughout in the Grade 1 SA Classic from draw 16 so was entitled to find no extra in the straight, finishing a 4,85 length tenth. In the Victory Moon Stakes last time out he had to do some work to overcome another wide draw. Yet he stayed on well for a 2,50 length second. He now has a good draw of three so should find cover and this will give him a chance of staying.

Strydom said he would have to give Astrix a chance due to the stamina doubt. He said the detractor in this case was the big field, as he might then end up too far back.

He concluded, “I don’t know the horse but it is an open race and if he stays he must have a chance.”

Astrix is 2,5kg better off with Christopher Robin for a 2,50 length beating in the Victory Moon so on paper should finish alongside that one, although the latter has no stamina concerns. 

Strydom’s four Summer Cup wins have been with Roland’s Song in 1990, Eventuail in 2002, Tyson in 2004 and Louis The King in 2014. 

Strydom intends retiring at the end of this season.

However, this depends on two things. Firstly, he wants to reach 5500 career winners. He should pass this mark before July 31 next year as he currently has only 29 winners to go.

He will also insist upon going out with a winner. If his last ride of the season is not a winner he will be back for another meeting next season.

He said, “I hope COVID-19 is over by then because after I have ridden that last winner I am going to throw my boots into the stands!”

An ambition before bowing out is to win the Vodacom Durban July next year and thus join Anton Marcus on a record five wins of the country’s premier horseracing event.

Five Summer Cup wins and five July’s will fit nicely as he will be the ripe age of 55 upon retiring.    

Michael Clower

RAINBOW BRIDGE, winner of the 2019 Sun Met and a string of other big races including the Champions Cup and the Gold Challenge, makes his eagerly-awaited reappearance in the Tabonline.co.za Pinnacle Stakes over 1 400m at Kenilworth today when rising star Luke Ferraris  will ride him in public for the first time.

The six-year-old opened a prohibitive 3-10 when World Sports Betting opened its book (on adjusted ratings he has the proverbial stone in hand). But there will be almost as much interest in African Night Sky who runs for the first time since his controversial run in the 2018 Vodacom Durban July.

“Rainbow Bridge has been doing pretty well but he is nowhere near fit yet,” said Eric Sands this morning. Sands is already eyeing the Green Point Stakes at the Cape Town course on December 12. “My aim is the L’Ormarins Queen’s Plate (Jan 9) and the Met three weeks later. I want the Queen’s Plate to be his third run back and the Met his fourth of the campaign because his second run of the season can be a little bit flat even though he always runs well in it. Luke rode the horse in a spin on Saturday and did so again this morning.”

Stable companion and half-brother Golden Ducat will return at Kenilworth on December 2. “We had a little hiccup with him so he is not as fit as he might be. He will gallop this week and will come back in a progress plate, either over a mile or over 1 200m.”

African Night Sky started a warm favourite for the 2018 July but the slow gallop proved fatal. He fought for his head and for rider Grant van Niekerk the race turned into a living nightmare. In a last, despairing throw of the dice he decided to give the horse his head and let him go. Not surprisingly his mount tired before the end and finished a bitterly expensive fifth. “They went slower and slower but I thought that if I went on the horse would settle,” Van Niekerk explained afterwards.

The jockey was widely, and unfairly, criticised by the riders in the stands – his mount’s defeat was guaranteed once he started fighting his jockey – and significantly this season’s leading Cape Town rider is back on him on Wednesday.

Owner Fred Crabbia transferred the horse from Justin Snaith to Dean Kannemeyer, possibly to race in Dubai, but he damaged a tendon and couldn’t go. He was returned to Snaith last December.

“Obviously he hasn’t raced for a long time but everything has gone well and I’m looking for a nice positive run,” said Justin today.

He also runs Wild Coast on whom Richard Fourie will be hoping to celebrate Wednesday’s 35^th birthday in appropriate style. “It’s a strong field but Wild Coast has been doing well at home and we are looking for a good run to give us confidence for the future, “ said the trainer.

Vaughan Marshall is also double-handed with Silver Operator and Captain Of Stealth who looked a future star when winning his first two races last season by an aggregate of almost 12 lengths. Then disaster struck. In a freak accident he wrapped himself below the joint and just above the coronet. Many thought he would never race again but Vaughan Marshall predicted ten months off.

He has had two runs this season and Marshall said today: ”He is just about back to his best but it hasn’t been plain sailing and he has had a lot of little minor issues including bouts of urticaria.”

The trainer probably has a better chance with his other runner Silver Operator, the mount of four-time champion Anton Marcus – “He has done very well and I am very happy with him.”

The Paul Reeves-trained Photocopy completes the line-up but he is the rank outsider.

Latest betting: 3-10 Rainbow Bridge, 8-1 Wild Coast, 17-2 Silver Operator, 15-1 African Night Sky, 18-1 Captain Of Stealth, 20-1 Photocopy.

YOU will have  received our penalty of R35 000 from the NHA in regards to  Herodotus’s positive identification for O-Desmethyltramadol, reports Glen Kotzen.

I would like to inform the public that this is the first time in South African racing history this product has been picked up in a racehorse and on receiving the identification I’m beyond shocked as this is not a veterinary product used in horses but a human pain killer. 

I have taken it upon myself to investigate the contamination from water source, environmental factors and human contamination and employed some of the best forensic experts both here and abroad. With thorough investigation together with SAP’s I together with my wife, Kathi,   found three staff members with IOD injuries in and around Herodotus’s win that were taking the medication which we have since learnt is routinely given to IOD patients who have undergone surgeries. 

Since this incident every employee in our employment  has to sign a  basic conditions of employment contract which includes declaring  and advising us of any schedule medication they are taking and we have also put up signage in our yard forbidding urination in and around our stable yard together with  general hand sanitization. 

Worldwide we have learnt that most O-Desmethyltramadol cases were human or environmental contamination.   Similarly Richard Hannon in the UK received many positives over many years for the same product and he was pulling his hair out not being able to find the source  –  https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/richard-hannon-fined-de-bruyne-horse-failed-drug-test-tramadol-metabolite-epsom-639033

Whilst we respect the part the NHA takes in protecting our industry and know the value of their service it is very sad that the strict liability clause ultimately makes me a guilty party and has caused our family tremendous emotional turmoil let alone the enormous financial losses we have incurred.

 Whilst I will not be appealing this ruling  as it is based purely on wrongful interpretation of the strict liability rule in this country which automatically renders one liable as the trainer of the horse that tested positive.

Abroad if a trainer can prove that they took all reasonable precautions  to prevent a positive finding then the authorities won’t make a finding against the trainer concerned.  I will, however, request the review board to look at the finding with regards to my case.

We would like to thank the owners of Herodotus who have from the very beginning stood by us whilst we investigated the cause of the contamination.