The handicappers have raised J&B Met winner Smart Call’s merit rating nine points to 121 after she put in officially the best performance by a filly in South Africa since the merit rating system was introduced here just before the turn of the century.
Smart Call is a member of one of the strongest female crops in South African history, if not the strongest in terms of depth, and she didn’t just beat the best males in the land on Saturday, she annihilated them and appeared to do it effortlessly.
If Legal Eagle had been used as the line horse she would have been accorded a 122, but the handicappers observed a number of horses had run exactly to their ratings, including the like of Punta Arenas and Gold Onyx, when compared to the performances of Captain America and Paterfamilias, so the latter pair were used as the measure.
Legal Eagle was said by the handicappers to have run to his 120 merit rating in the L’Ormarin’s Queen’s Plate and in the Met he confirmed form with all of the horses he had beaten in the former race, including Captain America, the disappointing pair Legislate and Futura, Gold Onyx, King Of Pain and Master Sabina.
Smart Call (Liesl King)
The only horse who could possibly detract from Smart Call’s win on Saturday would be the 4,8 length fourth-placed Light The Lights, who ran way above his 101 merit rating. However, he has always been talented and gelding has seen him realising his potential. The handicappers have duly raised him 10 points to 111.
Futura has been dropped two points to 117 after two disappointing runs in succession and the stallion paddock might be calling for him as he has little left to prove.
Smart Call was receiving a 2,5kg female allowance and 0,5kg four-year-old allowance on Saturday but also had to carry the 2kg Gr 1 penalty which all of Legal Eagle, Captain America, Legislate, Futura and Master Sabina had to carry, and she won by 3,5 lengths.
The filly Igugu’s J&B Met (2012) and Vodacom Durban July (2011)-winning performances were not as good as Smart Call’s on paper and neither was River Jetez’s 2010 Met win.
Ipi Tombe, like Igugu, won the July as a three-year-old but it was in a blanket finish, so she would not have been accorded a very high performance rating, although she did then go on to prove herself on the world stage.
The filly sprinters Val De Ra and Alboran Sea both had weight for age Gr 1 victories over horses who went on to be rated 121 and 120 respectively i.e. What A Winter and Captain Of All, but those victories came before the latter pair had reached those heights.
The great Empress Club destroyed the boys on a number of occasions in Gr 1 races, including beating July winner Flaming Rock in both the Queen’s Plate and the Met, and Smart Call likely has some way to go to be put alongside her, but the former ran in the days before merit ratings existed.
Smart Call is now on her way to the Breeders Cup and that stage will be the ultimate test of whether the handicappers have rated the cream of South African racing correctly.
By David Thiselton
